Mainstreaming the Issue of Corruption in the Forestry Sector
The curse of natural resources is not only happening in Africa, but also Indonesia: a country with abundant natural resources, yet entangled in severe structural poverty. The chasm between the rich and poor is gaping. According to Bisnis Indonesia daily (September 24, 2016), the Gini ratio of land ownership in Indonesia in 2016 was close to 0.58, meaning that 1% of the population controls 59% of agrarian, land and spatial resources.
Corruption is one of the causes. Permits are easily granted to forestry sector entrepreneurs, fueled by the practice of bribes to public officials, both at the central and regional levels. The forestry giants and their subsidiaries easily gain more control over forest land because of the easy access to permits. ICW has encouraged mainstreaming the issue of corruption in the forestry sector since 2012 with funding support from The Asia Foundation. This is based on the consideration that previous advocacy in the forestry sector focused more on issues of biodiversity threats, saving indigenous habitat, environmental damage and natural disasters. In 2015, KPK began to put the issue of natural resources as a priority issue.
In 2016, ICW began to spread the use of investigation of forestry sector corruption modules to various parties, including eight local NGOs spread across various regions and journalists. ICW also encouraged the reporting of forestry corruption cases, whether committed as an institutional initiative, or with ICW acting as a hub for local NGOs to report forestry corruption cases to the existing law enforcement agencies. About 18 reports of alleged forestry sector corruption have been submitted to law enforcement. Unfortunately, the law enforcement response is still very slow. In fact, the KPK is the sole institution pushing for the legal process of forestry sector corruption.
Jokowi's government has begun to respond and see the importance of forestry sector policy improvement, mainly due to severe environmental damage, frequent forest fires, increasing Gini ratio of lands (including forest tenure), as well as a response to international pressure as forests were considered as lungs of the world. The Government's own attitude seems quite clear in issuing a policy of moratorium on palm oil permits, given that the palm oil business is one of the biggest triggers of forest land conversion in Indonesia. Nevertheless, the struggle to encourage anti-corruption movements in the forestry sector still has many challenges, especially as the law enforcement has yet to show their initiative. ***
Kelompok masyarakat sipil melakukan aksi "Tolak Bala" di depan Gedung Merah-Putih KPK, 20 Desember 2019, menjelang pelantikan Pimpinan KPK dan Dewan Pengawas KPK Terpilih (Dok. ICW)
The participants of the Public Procurement Monitoring Training, representatives from local CSOs and journalists. Photo: NPPA, 2019